There is an interesting pocket of Indian music on 78 rpm where Indian musicians were integrating Western concepts and instruments such as the violin and piano into traditional Indian ensembles.
I don’t know anything about Mr. Suren Paul or the orchestra he directs here in the early 1930s – but listening to the music, I feel this music is 40 years ahead of its time.
It reminds me of a time in Western music where Indian concepts and instruments such as the sitar and tabla were being widely integrated into Western ensembles. Think of a group such as Ralph Towner’s Oregon from the early 1970s. “Music from Another Present Era” could have been Mr. Suren Paul’s grandchild.
In the late 1930s, Western music and instruments began to be seen as damaging to traditional Indian music. For example, the harmonium began to be seen as an “un-Indian” instrument not suitable for Indian classical music and in 1940 was banned outright from appearing on All India Radio.
An excellent article on this topic appears at:
https://www.heritagetimes.in/when-harmonium-was-banned-at-all-india-radio
I’m wondering if such orchestras also were discouraged from pursuing integrative music with Indian and Western instruments. I need to learn more about this.
Released as Senola QS 482
I believe this recording was made in Calcutta, India circa 1933.










